In addition to running my Music Production business, and creating content, I also do some work on behalf of PreSonus as a freelance Studio One clinician. Whenever I do any seminars, there are always a handful of Pro Tools users in the audience. And to be honest, the response I usually get is always the same. I’m paraphrasing here, but it goes a little something like this:
“I would love to use Studio One - and I do use it for my own production, but for certain projects, I have to work in Pro Tools - or at the very least, deliver a Pro Tools session. For this reason, I don’t use Studio One as much as I would like to.”
To which my reply is - In my humble opinion, Studio One has the best AAF Export workflow (with Pro Tools) that I have personally ever seen in a DAW. Meaning that I can get my whole entire Studio One Song - Over to Pro Tools, in minutes, no matter how complex it is, and whether I’m using Virtual Instruments or need to “Freeze” or “render” FX Plug-ins (such as Software Amp Simulators). It’s a really elegant solution.
Before I go any further, let’s address a few things quickly:
AAF is NOT a perfect translation - there is always something that needs to be taken into account.. This could be that it splits up stereo files to dual mono, or maybe the panning doesn’t always come across, or that it changes equal power Fades to linear. One BIG area for me, is that most AAF’s do not properly translate clip/region/event based gain - So your whole entire Gain staging could be off. This is just the way it is. And it has always been like this since I first starting using AAF’s. But In some cases, certain programs may handle one thing really nicely - but then they fail in other areas. But in all my time, I have never seen another DAW that can “hand off” an AAF to Pro Tools, and when it gets put back together - it’s not a complete disaster.
This is NOT about “DAW WARS” - I use Studio One because (for me) it’s the perfect fit, and I can work faster than I ever could in Pro Tools even when my Pro Tools chops were razor sharp. This is about a relatively painless workflow that can be used to get your Studio One Song over to Pro Tools when you need to! It’s also worth mentioning that I have done this (on the spot) in the middle of a session on more than one occasion when the situation called for it. ie: I was not able to track with my own interface, or computer, and had to use the Studio’s Computer / Pro Tools setup.
You don’t always need to deliver an AAF! - In fact, it may not be the best option. Before I create an AAF export, My first thought would probably be to Export Stems. This is a fantastic way to work, that’s used extensively in the industry. It’s super easy in Studio One, and there are also tons of different options in terms of exporting exactly what you need to deliver. If stems weren’t a good fit, then my next immediate thought would be to Export Raw Audio Files/Regions. In some cases, this may in fact be preferable. For example, If you were hired to deliver basic files, that are going to be mixed by someone else in another DAW all together. “Raw” audio Files consolidated to Bar 1 are great. BUT - When a song is in it’s production phase, where all the options are still on the table, and edits are not yet set in stone - nothing beats the flexibility of an AAF.
If this is something that seems like a familiar scenario, or you are someone that’s dabbling in Studio One, but still needs to deliver a Pro Tools session for your productions - then I hope this article / video helps!!
And as always, if you enjoy this content, please - Share, Subscribe, and hit that like button. :)
Cheers, Marcus
